Commit Graph

2 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
MarcoFalke
fb7b4bbdca Merge #19654: lint: Don't use TRAVIS_COMMIT_RANGE in commit message linter
72351784b3df21a89f79076f4b814a6e700b6469 lint: Remove travis env var from commit linter (Fabian Jahr)

Pull request description:

  #19439 was recently merged and seemed to work fine but I now noticed strange behavior when it was running in Travis, which I could not reproduce locally. It turns out `TRAVIS_COMMIT_RANGE` which is used in Travis to get the commits for the linter, uses all the commits that were in a push, which includes all rebase commits for example. This means that the linter can fail on a commit that the developer has never even seen before, which can be very confusing. See an example here which caused me to look into this: https://travis-ci.org/github/bitcoin/bitcoin/jobs/714296381 The commit that is reported as failing in my PR is not part of my PR.

  I think we rather want to use something like `git merge-base` to get the commit range by default and in Travis. I am leaving the env variable functionality in place with a different name but this is not a variable that can be expected to be present in the CI environments so the `merge-base` range should be used there by default.

ACKs for top commit:
  hebasto:
    ACK 72351784b3df21a89f79076f4b814a6e700b6469, I have reviewed the code and it looks OK, I agree it can be merged.

Tree-SHA512: afb27bb386855cb8d5cf84fd3a6c11ef1160b25af6175ed0aa146bf04b9a26eb77298df70df0a855f8c46f19f08b3f62c49872c12974fcfa5526a15ee05b3c10
2021-07-15 19:30:07 -05:00
MarcoFalke
7a92af887d Merge #19439: script: Linter to check commit message formatting
284a969cc082ae3c63ab523f22e71da86ad4ab20 Linter to check commit message formatting (Amir Ghorbanian)

Pull request description:

  Write linter to check that commit messages have a new line before the body or no body at all. fixes issue #19091.

ACKs for top commit:
  troygiorshev:
    ACK 284a969cc082ae3c63ab523f22e71da86ad4ab20 Reviewed, manually tested. Works great!
  fjahr:
    tested ACK 284a969cc082ae3c63ab523f22e71da86ad4ab20
  adamjonas:
    utACK 284a969cc082ae3c63ab523f22e71da86ad4ab20

Tree-SHA512: fa278f090780b54e4fa6e2967a62b4c1a4da55d112ec1ad6dd7e1181ac490c5c1af0165524b5781b463fdd6d0f79fd3d95b5160184e6eca432ccff1189f77390
2021-07-15 19:30:07 -05:00