07ddecb84e6097684fa56cfc79c8c2aad76f6604 refactor: Use [[maybe_unused]] attribute (Hennadii Stepanov)
55e0fc8df9c4045453982888732a0dd7c99ea6d1 refactor: Drop unneeded workarounds aimed to silence unused warning (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
This change is required for bitcoin/bitcoin#24773 as it prevents MSVC yelling about "warning C4551: function call missing argument list".
But it is useful by itself as it makes code more concise and readable.
ACKs for top commit:
Empact:
Code review ACK 07ddecb84e6097684fa56cfc79c8c2aad76f6604
laanwj:
Code review ACK 07ddecb84e6097684fa56cfc79c8c2aad76f6604
vincenzopalazzo:
ACK 07ddecb84e
w0xlt:
ACK 07ddecb
Tree-SHA512: 01791855a9ba742202d5718203303af989fcb501b7cf2a24ac8d78e87487acca38f77bef264b8e27e41ad1ccf96e426725cf65bfd96ce2ac71c46b3792bed857
3429d67014095b42a976d95c3ef8622d5fe085e6 init: Prevent -noproxy and -proxy=0 settings from interacting with other settings (Ryan Ofsky)
Pull request description:
Prevent `-noproxy` and `-proxy=0` settings from interacting with `-listen`, `-upnp`, and `-natpmp` settings.
These settings started being handled inconsistently in the `AppInitMain` and `InitParameterInteraction` functions starting in commit baf05075fa from #6272:
baf05075fa/src/init.cpp (L990-L991)baf05075fa/src/init.cpp (L687)
This commit changes both functions to handle proxy arguments the same way so
there are not side effects from specifying a proxy=0 setting.
This change was originally part of #24830 but really is independent and makes more sense as a separate PR
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 3429d67014095b42a976d95c3ef8622d5fe085e6, tested on Ubuntu 22.04.
Tree-SHA512: c4c6b4aeb3c07321700e974c16fd47a1bd3d469f273a6b308a69638db81c88c4e67208fddc96fcda9c8bd85f3ae22c98ca131c9622895edaa34eb65c194f35db
c71117fcb04fc2e45b5e76fe96b077a07b0c0f82 net: remove non-blocking bool from interface (Bushstar)
Pull request description:
SetSocketNonBlocking was added in 0.11 in the PR below with a second argument to toggle non-blocking mode for the socket. That argument has always been set to true in all subsequent releases and I'm not sure why it is present.
https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/4491
ACKs for top commit:
promag:
Code review ACK c71117fcb04fc2e45b5e76fe96b077a07b0c0f82.
lsilva01:
Code review ACK c71117fcb0
vasild:
ACK c71117fcb04fc2e45b5e76fe96b077a07b0c0f82
Tree-SHA512: feebfcfa75d997460a0ba42ffe1e0c25a7e0bfcad12510ad73ea4942cc1c653f9ad429adbbb00b9288fe319009552906fcb635a14dfd7dcbde3853baab6be065
a4f4f89815c5aadff51a7a11e0d63caf5212345a Replace uint256 specific implementations of base_uint::GetHex() and base_uint::SetHex() with proper ones that don't depend on uint256 and replace template methods instantiations of base_uint with template class instantiation (Samer Afach)
Pull request description:
The current implementations of `SetHex()` and `GetHex()` in `base_uint` use `arith_uint256`'s implementations. Which means, any attempt to create anything other than `arith_uint256` (say `arith_uint512`) and using any of these functions (which is what I needed in my application) will just not work and will cause compilation errors (besides the immediate linking errors due to templates being in source files instantiated only for 256) because there's no viable conversion from `arith_uint256` and any of the other possible types. Besides that these function will yield wrong results even if the conversion is possible depending on the size. This is fixed in this PR.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
re-ACK a4f4f89815c5aadff51a7a11e0d63caf5212345a
Tree-SHA512: 92a930fb7ddec5a5565deae2386f7d2d84645f9e8532f8d0c0178367ae081019b32eedcb59cc11028bac0cb15d9883228e016a466b1ee8fc3c6377b4df1d4180
e644591426fb4ee1bba5c4bfdde85eb378258272 build, refactor: Drop useless `call` Make function (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
Using the [`call`](https://www.gnu.org/software/make/manual/html_node/Call-Function.html) function with `$(package)_*_cmds` is effectively noop because the latter, which could be found in `<package>.mk` files, do not use temporary `$(1)` variable at all.
This PR removes useless calls of the `call` function, and makes code more readable and easier to reason about.
No change in resulted dependency binaries could be easy verified with bitcoin/bitcoin/#21995.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review ACK e644591426fb4ee1bba5c4bfdde85eb378258272
shaavan:
Code review ACK e644591426fb4ee1bba5c4bfdde85eb378258272
Tree-SHA512: 8481fa0dc5bbf7dd6a180f7fae5a2ccc07f85b50c7a966bceb2d7e010e07e5f211ee3f74f8ac79bc5acfde5f0764264d599d959ff3ebb8511b1b4a33f79509bd
e8e48fa82bdce3f0c1da0693148867befa221de7 Converted lint-python-mutable-default-parameters.sh to python (TakeshiMusgrave)
Pull request description:
This converts one of the linter scripts to Python. Reference issue: https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/24783
The approach is to just call git grep using subprocess.run.
Alternative approaches could be to use Python instead of git grep (I'm not sure how) or use ```pylint --disable=all --enable=W0102```, though that requires installation of pylint.
ACKs for top commit:
MarcoFalke:
review ACK e8e48fa82bdce3f0c1da0693148867befa221de7
Tree-SHA512: 7f6f4887dee02c9751b225a6a131fb705868859c4a9af25bb3485cda2358650486b110f17adf89d96a20f212d7d94899922a07aab12c8dc11984cfd5feb7a076
8b3f1e30f0f7bcd1a58efe29f57015ce03f64c50 Update RPC argument and field naming guideline in developer notes (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
Clarify the doc per the IRC discussion today at https://www.erisian.com.au/bitcoin-core-dev/log-2022-04-08.html#l-229.
ACKs for top commit:
mzumsande:
Code Review ACK 8b3f1e30f0f7bcd1a58efe29f57015ce03f64c50 - I agree with the added guideline.
Tree-SHA512: d0d06bc8d9587c0dc72545843097e48a4e27a9437ceca03c71d0aa4a9b8434971014687d8d2dd012b71e92b26d4ad116697365be3f2a8ed14daecfdb1d0982ef
b72925e7cea11522aca65580c136dbacb2753e83 lint: remove qt SIGNAL/SLOT lint (fanquake)
Pull request description:
I think we are past the point where we need to lint for this, the CPU
can probably be better utilized.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
ACK b72925e7cea11522aca65580c136dbacb2753e83
Tree-SHA512: 3da6e4811cdd16ff64c7e26f641f7b24f0405cc86cec36666de58691d447eca8662c924df31c6c60b3523c13590bdc62205a3237b1b1794dd8cdef35519309b3
112a7ab9a8e4c96f5750ac3b929b433d8507354c refactor: remove macOS MAP_ANONYMOUS work around (fanquake)
Pull request description:
This was added to support compilation on macOS 10.10, our minimum
required macOS is now 10.15. macOS has also supported it since 10.11.
See https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/9063.
macOS 12.3 manpage for mmap:
```bash
MAP_ANONYMOUS Synonym for MAP_ANON.
MAP_ANON Map anonymous memory not associated with any specific file.
```
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review ACK 112a7ab9a8e4c96f5750ac3b929b433d8507354c
jarolrod:
ACK 112a7ab9a8e4c96f5750ac3b929b433d8507354c
Tree-SHA512: 920744c755d05d813ab312ff27e42eacb27b1297972800e6fb64bbaad1ea14258751a7dd80c07bfa554a172f36960b26a07505f67e82885253c8bf551073c38e
e8fc236da70085d30c90cdade06edfa1da855a6c refactor: add missing std:: includes to threadnames.cpp (fanquake)
87f3c04cc539c34d32af5fd59abef2c0b5faee26 doc: remove incorrect mention of PR_GET_NAME (fanquake)
Pull request description:
By removing the whole comment. These `#include // For` comments are near impossible
to maintain, pollute diffs, and generally don't add a lot of value.
While here, also add the missing `std::` includes.
ACKs for top commit:
junderw:
LGTM ACK e8fc236
Tree-SHA512: d29aff40c94f59c42f295a5738bc5ff2f4a2f2e6d270cc505f27d56d07d272597e2f8403d72fe45775661e1a1fc2af9fc52aeaeb41263bd3e9dfe255332383c8
17648493df478fa9316cc9ed66fe6bc1c2c820a4 doc: Speed up functional test runs using ramdisk (willcl-ark)
Pull request description:
Using a ramdisk for the functional tests can give noticable speedups for developers and reviewers.
Local testing with an 8GB ramdisk saw a full test run using `test/functional/test_runner.py --jobs=100 --cachedir=/mnt/tmp/cache --tmpdir=/mnt/tmp` reduced from ~280 seconds to ~99 seconds.
Possible bikeshedding opportunity to be had over whether this might best fit into `doc/productivity.md`, but IMO more people will likely see it (and it will therefore be more useful) if it is here.
It seems best to select `tmpfs` over `ramfs` as `ramfs` can grow dynamically (good) but cannot be limited in size and might cause the system to hang if you run out of ram (bad), whereas `tmpfs` is size-limited and will overflow into swap.
ACKs for top commit:
josibake:
ACK 17648493df
jamesob:
ACK 17648493df
Tree-SHA512: b8e0846d4558a7a33fbb7cd190e30c36182db36095e1c1feae8c10a12042cff9d97739964bd9211d8564231dc99b4be5eed806d12a1d11dfa908157d7f26cc67
## Issue being fixed or feature implemented
Dead-code, useless conditions can be potential source of bug.
## What was done?
See each particular commit.
This particular commit "fix: check ptr in assert before usage" fixes
potential UB - `assert` is better than UB.
All other commits are not fixing any real issue, just to tidy-up code a
bit or to shut a potential warning.
## How Has This Been Tested?
Run unit/functional tests.
## Breaking Changes
N/A
## Checklist:
- [x] I have performed a self-review of my own code
- [ ] I have commented my code, particularly in hard-to-understand areas
- [ ] I have added or updated relevant unit/integration/functional/e2e
tests
- [ ] I have made corresponding changes to the documentation
- [x] I have assigned this pull request to a milestone
5a157eb3703e1e65ed285f13a824562ab12aa3ff Bugfix: configure: Only avoid -isystem for exact /usr/include path (Luke Dashjr)
556ee6f2fa0e2da2bb12fe05a885431f61db2e47 Bugfix: configure: Quote SUPPRESS_WARNINGS sufficiently to preserve brackets (Luke Dashjr)
Pull request description:
The regex includes `[/ ]` which is supposed to match either a forward slash or a space, but m4 treats the brackets as special characters and effectively strips them out, leading to -isystem /usr/include paths except for in the typical scenario where it is the final parameter in the flag string.
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 5a157eb3703e1e65ed285f13a824562ab12aa3ff, tested on Ubuntu 22.04 with clang 14.0.
vasild:
ACK 5a157eb3703e1e65ed285f13a824562ab12aa3ff
Tree-SHA512: 5c8c282b647b7853b8fad1b5b473703c4a0635073d2685a8ac984151046e2c6a859e6972465419d27356dd29a47f21a2a3a6ad402ec434fe1f9882e5a35f0749
f8cba0d9117fe9b9ac51d7044372b28270c7838b test: Change default test logging directory (Yancy Ribbens)
Pull request description:
This PR changes the default test log location request here: https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/17224. Instead of using the location of the makefile [automatic variable](https://www.gnu.org/software/make/manual/make.html#Automatic-Variables) `$<` I extract just the basename and then prepend a new location `./test`. This is done because `$<` represents the variable name AND location of the prerequisite here.
Top commit has no ACKs.
Tree-SHA512: f0fbc530cf0e14c284b4bbf6671c145b1d7a2e1f5561f5c5d09f0cbe88b98e620e763bbbf2dfa9aeeec3dcc9b0127939e105e14c7e4f6660c7c19663622a393d
28f17c1a6de7b50482d8f55fe03698126862e8eb build: fix copypasta in OpenBSD C{XX} flags (fanquake)
Pull request description:
Introduced in #23998.
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 28f17c1a6de7b50482d8f55fe03698126862e8eb, I have reviewed the code and it looks OK, not tested on OpenBSD though.
Tree-SHA512: d905161534075f518c8924d3c42cca7ff8d4898e559f1daa9bd03dac95b109b2c3e76790fb8bc65b9e45e8a59566825afbf4dc3734ad74617dfdf797430e486b
061accfddd2d27ad584c826413c68857d2be9ced build: require libtool 2.4.2 (fanquake)
Pull request description:
Every system we support has 2.4.6 available, except for OpenBSD, which
[currently ships with 2.4.2](https://github.com/openbsd/ports/blob/master/devel/libtool/Makefile) (released 2011). For now, set our minimum
required version to that.
After a 7 year hitus, 2.4.7 has also very recently been released:
https://savannah.gnu.org/forum/forum.php?forum_id=10139.
Partially motivated by comments in https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/24615.
See also: https://repology.org/project/libtool/versions
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK 061accfddd2d27ad584c826413c68857d2be9ced
hebasto:
ACK 061accfddd2d27ad584c826413c68857d2be9ced
prusnak:
ACK 061accfddd2d27ad584c826413c68857d2be9ced
Tree-SHA512: bc032022b8609b73253ff1c4fd480f4d09be761b8fec295f39319f9499ee2df116f55295da476be551c43ed88fbb0bfed7bb5a188b9979b34147fe39737ec76f
38a1b0b1967272cbb984f37bcc86b6640930319f doc: remove unneeded documentation on basic package management on FreeBSD (jessebarton)
Pull request description:
In reference to #24618
ACKs for top commit:
fanquake:
ACK 38a1b0b1967272cbb984f37bcc86b6640930319f - Thanks. In future, please re-use existing PRs, so that discussion and changes are kept together.
Tree-SHA512: ece5b85bca7f11e11d47c0674a6b96a72c3bb65dd02ab25553db511a001a9fc682c0ff8276e39d979fdd1f57a64137f586cfa548aab5c08cd9341455217b9181
339b4a51f6d3558c3489b14efe0c8c195295cf86 build: don't install deprecated libevent headers (fanquake)
Pull request description:
We don't use the deprecated headers now, and never should do in the
future, so there is no need for them to exist in depends.
The headers themselves are just full of includes for the newer headers.
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 339b4a51f6d3558c3489b14efe0c8c195295cf86
Tree-SHA512: 736fd9e3b22212da462cc05203dd253806dc59f973090357b705f2742ed4a3b8c3cc44b3173d706527f60ad93e95cf4143ec6b7db4233a489890a98f8e5c8f07
e7fc50681e99e3c726db2bc4d3d425ed8a0fc6b3 qt: Override BitcoinApplication::event() to handle QEvent::Quit (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
bitcoin-core/gui#336 introduced a regression when termination requests from a platform are not handled properly.
This PR fixes this regression. On macOS shutdown after clicking "Quit" in Dock icon menu, and during logout works again.
Fixes bitcoin-core/gui#545.
ACKs for top commit:
RandyMcMillan:
tACK e7fc50681e99e3c726db2bc4d3d425ed8a0fc6b3
Sjors:
tACK e7fc50681e99e3c726db2bc4d3d425ed8a0fc6b3 (rebased on master) indeed fixes the crash described in #545
promag:
Tested ACK e7fc50681e99e3c726db2bc4d3d425ed8a0fc6b3 on macOS 10.15 with Qt 5.15.2.
Tree-SHA512: 236a483dc0828f22999469e133b8ac9f0b6267ec2a27004c3ebaa967689ddb972ea1fa90c1dd41f3bff3d17bf571a707babcef53bd79fd711fda98cfbf120131
faa7d8a3f7cba02eca7e247108a6b98ea9daf373 util: Add SaturatingAdd helper (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Seems good to have this in the repo, as it might be needed to write cleaner code. For example:
* https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/24090#issuecomment-1019948200
* https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/23418#discussion_r744953272
* ...
ACKs for top commit:
MarcoFalke:
Added a test. Should be trivial to re-ACK with `git range-diff bitcoin-core/master fa90189cbf faa7d8a3f7`
klementtan:
reACK faa7d8a3f7
vasild:
ACK faa7d8a3f7cba02eca7e247108a6b98ea9daf373
Tree-SHA512: d0e6efdba7dfcbdd16ab4539a7f5e45a97d17792e42586c3c52caaae3fc70612dc9e364359658de5de5718fb8c2a765a59ceb2230098355394fa067a9732bc2a
71d33380ed6858b4a65b396332bfb22d984642a6 qt: prevent negative values of progressPerHour (HiLivin)
Pull request description:
Added a similar guard to _progressPerHour_ as is placed at _remainingMSecs_.
It prevents the display of negative values like "-0.00%" in some cases.
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 71d33380ed6858b4a65b396332bfb22d984642a6
jarolrod:
ACK 71d3338
shaavan:
reACK 71d33380ed6858b4a65b396332bfb22d984642a6
Tree-SHA512: 5427cdf4441b542196008034355ea00a075adf8b9aeeb383bacdb4e5fbda23d665448a50035aac93cbf401d5d6211d39a2c7c294568d9f5548a5c7579e201c44
faa5e171e6bdb8f3b4027a3f06497f0de5abf766 RPCConsole: Throw when overflowing size_t type for array indices (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
To test:
-> `getblock(getbestblockhash(), 1)[tx][22222222222222222222222222222]`
Before:
<- `868693731dea69a197c13c2cfaa41c9f78fcdeb8ab8e9f8cdf2c9025147ee7d1` (hash of the coinbase tx)
After:
<- `Error: Invalid result query`
ACKs for top commit:
jarolrod:
ACK faa5e171e6bdb8f3b4027a3f06497f0de5abf766
shaavan:
ACK faa5e17
Tree-SHA512: ddff39aae1c15db45928b110a9f1c42eadc5404cdfa89d67ccffc4c6af24091967d43c068ce9e0c1b863cfc4eb5b4f12373a73756a9474f8294e8a44aabc28d8
9bd168bf5457c6fd9770769547d8757bf14813b0 qt: add missing tooltips to options menu settings (Jarol Rodriguez)
Pull request description:
This adds missing tooltips to the text of the `Size of database cache` and the `Number of script verification threads` settings.
All settings in the Options window will now have appropriate tooltip texts.
ACKs for top commit:
jonatack:
ACK 9bd168bf5457c6fd9770769547d8757bf14813b0 tested on Debian 5.10.46-4 (2021-08-03)
hebasto:
ACK 9bd168bf5457c6fd9770769547d8757bf14813b0, tested on Linux Mint 20.2 (Qt 5.12.8).
Tree-SHA512: d71946bfee33c624a8b79eafe514d2c902090a40bc25097be4c7da4a80270f53305002af1b27d5fd082a0f45f838e22036632f9445918c4b8898073b33c09c08
93cc53a2b27eeb05fe00b8bf17465037815473a1 gui: Unregister wallet notifications before unloading wallets (Russell Yanofsky)
Pull request description:
This change was originally part of both bitcoin/bitcoin#10102 and bitcoin/bitcoin#19101 and is required for both because it avoids the IPC wallet implementation in bitcoin/bitcoin#10102 and the WalletContext implementation in bitcoin/bitcoin#19101 needing to deal with notification objects that have stale pointers to deleted wallets.
ACKs for top commit:
promag:
Code review ACK 93cc53a2b27eeb05fe00b8bf17465037815473a1.
hebasto:
ACK 93cc53a2b27eeb05fe00b8bf17465037815473a1
Tree-SHA512: 805f50a493291ad0f7c48725fbc5058d58ebbdb0770befd51d8aa241209a13f8a46f5982481336ab8338cdc83e9017668089a71deccf1587308e841cf8697825
87651795d8622d354f8e3c481eb868d9433b841c fuzz: check that ser+unser produces the same AddrMan (Vasil Dimov)
6408b24517f3418e2a408071b4c2ce26571f3167 fuzz: move init code to the CAddrManDeterministic constructor (Vasil Dimov)
Pull request description:
Add a fuzz test that fills addrman with a pile of randomly generated addresses, serializes it to a stream, unserializes the stream to another addrman object and compares the two.
Some discussion of this already happened at https://github.com/jnewbery/bitcoin/pull/18.
ACKs for top commit:
practicalswift:
cr ACK 87651795d8622d354f8e3c481eb868d9433b841c
jonatack:
ACK 87651795d8622d354f8e3c481eb868d9433b841c rebased to current master, reviewed, fuzz build, ran `FUZZ=addrman_serdeser src/test/fuzz/fuzz`
Tree-SHA512: 7eda79279f14f2649840bf752e575d7b02cbaad541f74f7254855ebd4a32da988f042d78aa9228983350283bb74dd0c71f51f04c0846889c3ba2f19f01a0c303
bcd36e14f0a2b89445f1436094de40696d6ad76c build: correct depends FreeBSD C{XX}FLAGS (fanquake)
7b06ffce9c50110b475c722918c55a14402346a5 build: add NetBSD support to depends (fanquake)
Pull request description:
Similar to #23948. Doesn't build the Qt package; I haven't looked at doing that yet, but have an assumption that it's going to fail out of the box similar to the FreeBSD build.
Guix Build:
```bash
```
ACKs for top commit:
theuni:
ACK bcd36e14f0a2b89445f1436094de40696d6ad76c
Tree-SHA512: 9a0946cefbcb9a92dd730b885463f3213e304c8d4b39fea8d831fc013a73d2ef998ca84e384bf45a01fa1449cf5a35eaffaa5b57a9062c2cdda34312d33ec3fc
fadd73037e266edb844f0972e82e9213171ef214 refactor: Remove implicit-integer-sign-change suppressions in validation.cpp (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
A file-wide suppression is problematic because it will wave through future violations, potentially bugs.
Fix that by using per-statement casts.
ACKs for top commit:
shaavan:
ACK fadd73037e266edb844f0972e82e9213171ef214
theStack:
Code-review ACK fadd73037e266edb844f0972e82e9213171ef214
Tree-SHA512: a8a05613be35382b92d7970f958a4e8f4332432056eaa9d72f6719495134b93aaaeea692899d9035654d0e0cf56bcd759671eeeacfd0535582c0ea048ab58a56
b062da009001c1beb362169d700663d7220eef5e contrib: add check for wget command in install_db4.sh (Florian Baumgartl)
Pull request description:
This PR is motivated by 7bb8eb0bc3 commit (see also https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/23579) and ensures that `install_db4.sh` will check for `curl` and `wget` utilities. Currently, the conditional statement in the `http_get()` function assumes that `wget` is always available but we actually do not know it since there is no check or validation for the `wget` command. So let's make sure that we check for both commands and print an error message if they are missing.
ACKs for top commit:
jamesob:
ACK b062da0090
laanwj:
Tested ACK b062da009001c1beb362169d700663d7220eef5e
shaavan:
ACK b062da009001c1beb362169d700663d7220eef5e
Tree-SHA512: bfc1ccad9a5b99764b759e02dde1976616c2af4747b7d5af8e71d33624c2cb21d93a09a60d244756e86bbd5fd7541331c62d7eb84d3458b6a059f1d9cb2a5f42
c055f6b216659b844c8dcd4ff2a977f181099678 test: Remove false coinstatsindex test (Fabian Jahr)
Pull request description:
This test never actually tested the behavior that it describes in the comments. This was discovered in #21590 which seems to speed up muhash which lead to the test failing.
I can vaguely remember that the described behavior was desired by some reviewers of `coinstatsindex`: That `coinstatsindex` should be aware of stale blocks and able to return statistics on them as well. The index actually does this for blocks that it sees while the index is active, i.e. while running `coinstatsindex` all blocks will be indexed and even when they become stale the index (via `gettxoutsetinfo`) will still return a result for them when given the right hash. But this currently does not work for blocks that the node saw and that became stale _before_ the node activated `coinstatsindex`. While the index syncs initially everything but the active chain is ignored and I don't see any indication that this ever worked differently in the past.
Introducing this behavior seems non-trivial at first glance so, while I will give this a shot, I think the test should be removed so it does not confuse users and does not block #21590.
Top commit has no ACKs.
Tree-SHA512: b05f5dfeea3e453c8bb7c761501d0d896d4412a3f0c08037955951fae9fe388c63402da401792591e18da8fb67734f47f1a297d573cdb66e0ced451698718067
7bb8eb0bc352b47ee962283898f9becbb4f36c62 script install_db4.sh added check for patch command (Nathan Garabedian)
Pull request description:
First contribution. I've read the CONTRIBUTING guide and hope I'm doing this correctly, but please kindly point out anything I should do differently.
I found while running the contrib/install_db4.sh patch that it would fail suddenly with "patch: command not found". I'd rather see it fail early before doing any work, allow me to install the `patch` command, and then run again. (CentOS Linux) Here's a PR proposed to fix it.
error message:
```
...
db-4.8.30.NC/txn/txn_rec.c
db-4.8.30.NC/txn/txn_region.c
db-4.8.30.NC/txn/txn_stat.c
db-4.8.30.NC/txn/txn_util.c
./contrib/install_db4.sh: line 71: patch: command not found
```
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review and tested ACK 7bb8eb0bc352b47ee962283898f9becbb4f36c62
Tree-SHA512: f0c59ec509dff6637c41eec2923fe708456c3a7ae04495b12c5492681a1f95d1d9a643a2649df13ba8e6ac708680c627657b6989b62eff63be021e92e1d7c4a8
33c6a208a9e2512a174c99c224a933a59f091bc2 span, doc: provide span.h context and explain lifetimebound definition (Jon Atack)
d14395bc5db55331115fa3c1e71741d1de7f092f net, doc: provide context for UnserializeV1Array() (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
Add contextual documentation for developers and future readers of the code regarding
- CNetAddr::UnserializeV1Array (see #22140)
- Span and why it defines Clang lifetimebound locally rather than using the one in attributes.h
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Documentation review ACK 33c6a208a9e2512a174c99c224a933a59f091bc2
Tree-SHA512: cb8e6a6c23b36c9ef7499257e97c5378ec895bb9122b79b63b572d9721a1ae6ce6c0be7ad61bdf976c255527ae750fc9ff4b3e03c07c6c797d14dbc82ea9fb3a
ef72e9bd4124645fe2d00521a71c1c298d760225 doc: nChainTx needs to become a 64-bit earlier due to SegWit (Sjors Provoost)
Pull request description:
As of block 597,379 txcount is 460,596,047 (see `chainparams.cpp`), while `uint32` can handle up to 4,294,967,296.
Pre segwit the [minimum transaction size](https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Maximum_transaction_rate) was 166 bytes, so the worst case number of transactions per block was ~6000. As the original source comment for `unsigned int nChainTx` says, that should last until the year 2030.
With SegWit the smallest possible transaction is 60 bytes (potentially increased to 65 with a future soft fork, see #15482), without a witness:
```
4 bytes version
1 byte input count
36 bytes outpoint
1 byte scriptSigLen (0x00)
0 bytes scriptSig
4 bytes sequence
1 byte output count
8 bytes value
1 byte scriptPubKeyLen
1 byte scriptPubKey (OP_TRUE)
4 bytes locktime
```
That puts the maximum number of transactions per block at 16,666 so we might have to deal with this as early as a block 827,450 in early 2024.
Given that it's a memory-only thing and we want to allow users many years to upgrade, I would suggest fixing this in v0.20 and back-porting it.
ACKs for top commit:
practicalswift:
re-ACK ef72e9bd4124645fe2d00521a71c1c298d760225
jarolrod:
ACK ef72e9bd4124645fe2d00521a71c1c298d760225
theStack:
ACK ef72e9bd4124645fe2d00521a71c1c298d760225
Tree-SHA512: d8509ba7641796cd82af156354ff3a12ff7ec0f7b11215edff6696e95f8ca0e3596f719f3492ac3acb4b0884ac4e5bddc76f107b656bc2ed95a8ef1b2b5d4f71
350e034e64d175f3db4c85ddca42e76e279912f6 consensus: don't call GetBlockPos in ReadBlockFromDisk without lock (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
Commit ccd8ef65 "Reduce cs_main lock in ReadBlockFromDisk, only read GetBlockPos under the lock" in #11281 moved the cs_main lock from caller to `ReadBlockFromDisk()` for calling `CBlockIndex::GetBlockPos()`, but the second invocation doesn't have the lock, and IIUC there is no guarantee the compiler can know if state has changed.
Use the `blockPos` local variable instead, rename it to `block_pos`, and make it const.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
Code review ACK 350e034e64d175f3db4c85ddca42e76e279912f6
theStack:
Code-review ACK 350e034e64d175f3db4c85ddca42e76e279912f6
promag:
Code review ACK 350e034e64d175f3db4c85ddca42e76e279912f6.
Tree-SHA512: 0df0614ab1876885c85f7b53c604a759a29008da8027e95503b4726d2b820ec6d27546020c613337ff954406e01cb5d191978ba4a12124052fed6e1b0e9a226f
317442525586ba9ff8b9af6c506b48f87cd8cd87 Cleanup headers after #20788 (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
This is a header cleanup after #20788.
ACKs for top commit:
vasild:
ACK 317442525586ba9ff8b9af6c506b48f87cd8cd87
Tree-SHA512: 1c21b1ba43841880625289174f10e5b333f6eb857f448e1e4114b1ecdf32a6044ec91c5987c1d66806c1d408a4e3d46569eb41d69a0acb8296601d7c203d9f1d
56a42f10f452f0ac0e3e333646a8effcbebf6b30 Stricter BIP32 decoding and test vector 5 (Pieter Wuille)
Pull request description:
This adds detection for various edge cases when decoding BIP32 extended pubkeys/privkeys, and tests them using the proposed https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/pull/921 BIP32 test vector 5.
ACKs for top commit:
darosior:
utACK 56a42f10f452f0ac0e3e333646a8effcbebf6b30 -- Had to implement essentially the same fix in python-bip32.
kristapsk:
ACK 56a42f10f452f0ac0e3e333646a8effcbebf6b30. Checked that test vectors are the same as in BIP32 and that tests pass.
Tree-SHA512: 5cc800cc9dc10e43ae89b659ce4f44026d04ec3cabac4eb5122d2e72ec2ed66cd5ace8c7502259e469a9ecaa5ecca2457e55dfe5fedba59948ecbf6673af67a7
## Issue being fixed or feature implemented
Cache population for old quorums is a cpu heavy operation and should be
avoided for inactive quorums _at least_ oin `ScanQuorums`. This issue is
critical for testnet and other small network because every mn
participate in almost every platform quorum and cache population for 2
months of quorums can easily block everything for 15+ minutes on a 4 cpu
node. On mainnet quorum distribution is much better but it's still a
small waste of cpu (or not so small for unlucky nodes).
#5761 follow-up
## What was done?
Do not start cache population for outdated quorums, improve logs in
`StartCachePopulatorThread` to make it easier to see what's going on.
## How Has This Been Tested?
run a mn on testnet
## Breaking Changes
n/a
## Checklist:
- [x] I have performed a self-review of my own code
- [ ] I have commented my code, particularly in hard-to-understand areas
- [ ] I have added or updated relevant unit/integration/functional/e2e
tests
- [ ] I have made corresponding changes to the documentation
- [x] I have assigned this pull request to a milestone _(for repository
code-owners and collaborators only)_
